Thoughts on… Alone in the Dark (2005)

alone_in_the_dark_xlgEarly this morning I participated in the fourth Shitfest Social, where a whole bunch of film bloggers get together and watch a film at the same time and make snarky comments about it, hosted by the wonderful Cinema Parrot Disco and Isaacs Picture Conclusions. This time around we were watching Alone in the Dark (2005), and it was a lot of fun commenting with everyone! Here’s the big thread with all our comments on the ridiculousness of this film.

Additionally, there was an earlier Shitfest Social that I unfortunately didn’t get to participate in. If you want to read roughly 300 comments about a film called Axe Giant: The Wrath of Paul Bunyan (2013), have a look here! It sounds like it might be a great film, maybe.

Here’s the synopsis for Alone in the Dark:

Based on the video game, Alone in the Dark focuses on Edward Carnby, a detective of the paranormal, who slowly unravels a mysterious event with deadly results. (source)

And here are some thoughts that occurred to me whilst watching this film this morning.

  1. The film starts with what feels like ten minutes of exposition on the screen – both scrolling text and narration. In other words, it’s a really great way to start an action-packed horror film!
  2. Alone in the Dark is considered one of the worst films ever made. It currently holds a 1% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Nothing much else to say about that. I agree, it’s really bad.
  3. This film is based on a series of video games, and amalgamates a number of plot points from each game into the one film (apparently). As a result, it feels choppy and weird. It’s like all the story elements are mismatched. I think this could have been a pretty effective horror/sci fi thriller if they had stuck to one concept (e.g. just the orphanage, or just the paranormal agency) and explored it better. And if they had better actors. And a better director.
  4. Can anyone think of a video game that’s been turned into a good film? I can’t think of any. Except Super Mario Bros (1993), which some people say is bad, but I think it’s kind of fun.
  5. This film was either directed by Uwe Boll, or by someone who needs to have their eyes tested for macular degeneration. The direction was just horrible. There’s random zooming, slow-mo, swooping and panning all over the place, and it’s almost like he wanted to include every directorial trick in every scene. It was so dumb. I think I actually laughed at one point where the camera suddenly zoomed in on Christian Slater’s face because it had happened something like three times already.
  6. Oh, and the CGI is really bad. But that almost goes without saying.
  7. The acting is also terrible. I don’t think I’ve seen Christian Slater in one good film (edit:Β Except Heathers (1988), which I love!). He’s the lead in this one so we get to see a lot of him squinting and attempting to look heroic, but it just doesn’t work. Stephen Dorff isn’t too bad in this but his curly mullet-style haircut is totally distracting.
  8. Tara Reid is not good in this film. She’s meant to be the scientist slash archaeologist slash assistant curator of an ancient artifacts exhibit or museum or something, but her performance reminded me of how we’re meant to believe that Denise Richards is a nuclear physicist in The World Is Not Enough (1999). Nope.
  9. Finally, this image of Tara Reid pretending to be a scientist/archaeologist/curator expresses all of my feelings about this film:


Watch this film at Amazon!


  1. I just watched this film this afternoon. What an epically bad load of old crap!

    1. Totally! I just can’t get over the fact that someone spent 20 million dollars on it!

  2. I can’t think of any really good video game movies either. There is a mini web series for Halo Forward Unto Dawn that I thought was fairly good, but it’s not a film.

    1. I still can’t think of a good video game film! Apart from Super Mario Bros.

  3. Silent Hill turned into a good film, i think video games need to be turned into a TV series to tell the full story

    1. I haven’t seen Silent Hill yet, maybe I should. The game was pretty creepy!

  4. Hahaha! This was great fun watching this with you, Anna. God this was bad! And Tara Reid… Ugh! Why is she even IN movies?? But… “I don’t think I’ve seen Christian Slater in one good film.” – Aww! Really?? Heathers & Pump Up The Volume are two of my favorite movies EVER! : ) And loads of people love True Romance (I’ve never seen it, though).

    1. Holy crud, I totally forgot about Heathers! So I had to go and edit this immediately! Love that film. I’ve always meant to see True Romance too. I should be more open-minded about Christian Slater! Tara Reid is in those Sharknado films too. Maybe that should be the next CPD Shitfest Social? πŸ˜€

      1. Lol. I’d be fine with that! I kind of want to see that one. ; )

  5. Tara Reid… oh dear… her level of awareness that she was even in a movie looks like about a 4/10 throughout.

    1. Poor Tara Reid. I really wonder whether she puts in a better performance in that Sharknado film!

      1. I’m not sure I’m willing to watch it to find out.

  6. You never mentioned the bizarre sex scene that just came out of nowhere! It was at that point I started my descent into madness

    1. To be honest, I totally forgot about it immediately after it happened! Absolutely ridiculous.

      1. I wish I could forget about it 😦

        1. Nothing worse than a nightmare about a sex scene with Tara Reid in it.

  7. . . . .I’m still reeling from grief from my lack of participation in either of these. I told Mr. Isaacs I would. . .and then I found out I was working all day the day these were happening. I feel sad. 😦

    Especially since I saw how good these commentaries are! lol

    1. Never fear, there’s always next time! πŸ˜€ Shitfest Social is a lot of fun!

  8. Too funny I wish I could have watched with you guys!!!

    1. Next time! πŸ˜€

  9. Haha, that’s an awesome picture of Tara Reid! You’re right, it totally captures the movie. A picture is worth a thousand words, as they say.

    1. She looks perpetually confused the whole time, it’s amazing! And it helps the audience to relate to the fact that the film is a massive mess.

  10. I’m sad that I missed the chance to make fun of this movie…but I’m a tiny bit grateful that I didn’t have to sit through it because this sounds God awful. Bahahaha. πŸ˜‰

    1. Haha! Yeah, it was really bad. But Shitfest Social is always fun!

      1. That’s very true. The awesome people outweigh the shitty film. πŸ™‚

What do you think? Leave a comment here!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: